Researched rankings in 38 cities across the United States and Canada, each with a last-reviewed date.

TenBestFindThe best, verified
Add Your Business

Roofing · Buffalo, NYLast reviewed October 2026

7 Best Roofing Companies in Buffalo, NY (2026)

TenBestFind ranks 7 roofing companies in Buffalo, NY. Each company was checked against the criteria set out under How we chose. Lists name up to ten companies, and this one stops at 7 because only 7 met them. Marcus Reed last reviewed the list on October 22, 2026.

Buffalo's Best Roofing Company leads our Buffalo list with 4.9 stars from 774 Google reviews and round-the-clock storm tarping. Seven roofers cleared our bar of 4.5 stars, 50 reviews and a real staffed address, and we list them in Google's order as read on October 22, 2026.

The Ranking

Our top 7 roofing companies in Buffalo

Buffalo roofs fight lake-effect snow, heavy ice dams and a freeze and thaw cycle that lifts flashing and shingle edges every winter. Many houses in the East Side, Black Rock and South Buffalo are older two-family homes with several layers of shingles, so ask whether the crew tears down to the deck and what they do about ice and water shield at the eaves. New York State does not license roofers, but Erie County requires a home improvement license, so check any contractor on the Erie County Department of Consumer Protection lookup, then ask for a workers' compensation certificate, a liability insurance certificate and the permit for your address. Several companies on this list are based in nearby towns such as Cheektowaga and Williamsville, and each listing says where the office is.

Showing 7 of 7
  1. 01

    Best for fast residential re-roofs and storm repairs in Buffalo's eastern suburbs

    Buffalo's Best Roofing Company LLC

    4.9(773 Google reviews)
    Best forFast residential re-roofs and storm repairs in Buffalo's eastern suburbs
    In businessNot listed
    WarrantyNot listed
    EmergencyAvailable

    Why we picked them

    4.9 from 774 Google reviews, the deepest review base on this list, plus CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster status and 24/7 storm response.

    What we like

    • 774 Google reviews at 4.9 stars
    • Storm tarping and ice dam removal around the clock
    • Financing up to 72 months

    Things to consider

    • The office is in Cheektowaga, and 20 of 774 reviews are one star.

    Services

    • Roof repair
    • Roof replacement
    • Roof inspection
    • Metal roofing
    • Flat roofing
    • Storm damage repair
    Key details
    Best for
    Fast residential re-roofs and storm repairs in Buffalo's eastern suburbs
    Service area
    Buffalo
    Address
    4589 Genesee St, Cheektowaga, NY
    Emergency service
    Available
    Financing
    Available
    Credentials
    CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster
  2. 02

    Best for storm damage and insurance claim roof replacements

    Buffalo Roofing

    4.8(397 Google reviews)
    Best forStorm and insurance claim roof replacements
    In businessNot listed
    WarrantyCompany labor warranty that matches the manufacturer's 10, 20, 30, 40 or 50 year material warranty, depending on the roofing material chosen.
    EmergencyAvailable

    Why we picked them

    4.8 from 398 Google reviews, with two insurance claims specialists and a labor warranty matched to the manufacturer's term.

    What we like

    • Two staff dedicated to insurance claims using Xactimate
    • Labor warranty matched to the manufacturer's 10 to 50 years
    • Showroom open to the public at 5565 Transit Road

    Things to consider

    • Based in Williamsville, and no founding year, license or insurance details are published.

    Services

    • Roof repair
    • Roof replacement
    • Roof inspection
    • Metal roofing
    • Flat roofing
    • Storm damage repair
    Key details
    Best for
    Storm and insurance claim roof replacements
    Service area
    Buffalo
    Address
    5565 Transit Rd, Williamsville, NY
    Warranty
    Company labor warranty that matches the manufacturer's 10, 20, 30, 40 or 50 year material warranty, depending on the roofing material chosen.
    Emergency service
    Available
    Financing
    Available
    Credentials
    Licensed and insured (company statement, no numbers published)
  3. 03

    Best for full tear-offs on older Buffalo homes

    Mann Roofing and Remodeling

    4.7(146 Google reviews)
    Best forFull tear-offs and storm repairs on older Buffalo homes
    In business19 years
    WarrantyManufacturer material warranties through its Owens Corning and CertainTeed certified installation, registered on the finished roof. Specific workmanship warranty length is not stated on the website.
    EmergencyAvailable

    Why we picked them

    4.7 from 146 Google reviews, in business since 2007 from a Pratt Street base with Owens Corning and CertainTeed certified installers.

    What we like

    • Full tear-offs down to the deck, often finished in a day
    • Owens Corning and CertainTeed certified installers
    • Free estimates and HEARTH financing

    Things to consider

    • Recent reviewers report weeks-long waits for an estimate and a remodel that ran late.

    Services

    • Roof repair
    • Roof replacement
    • Roof inspection
    • Metal roofing
    • Flat roofing
    • Storm damage repair
    Key details
    Best for
    Full tear-offs and storm repairs on older Buffalo homes
    Service area
    Buffalo
    Address
    237 Pratt St
    Years in business
    19 years
    Warranty
    Manufacturer material warranties through its Owens Corning and CertainTeed certified installation, registered on the finished roof. Specific workmanship warranty length is not stated on the website.
    Emergency service
    Available
    Financing
    Available
    Credentials
    Owens Corning certified installer
  4. 04

    Best for a fast full replacement from a large, financed crew

    Stellar Roofing

    4.6(532 Google reviews)
    Best forHomeowners who want a fast full replacement from a large, financed operation
    In businessNot listed
    WarrantyLabor and material warranties are advertised; lengths are not published on the website, so ask for the written terms.
    EmergencyAvailable

    Why we picked them

    4.6 from 532 Google reviews, with one-day tear-offs and project managers who send progress photos.

    What we like

    • Triple-layer tear-off finished in a single day
    • Project managers named in reviews for photo updates
    • Financing with up to 18 months of no payments for approved buyers

    Things to consider

    • A recent review reports ice damming and unanswered requests for a visit after a job.

    Services

    • Roof repair
    • Roof replacement
    • Metal roofing
    • Storm damage repair
    Key details
    Best for
    Homeowners who want a fast full replacement from a large, financed operation
    Service area
    Buffalo
    Address
    25 John Glenn Dr
    Warranty
    Labor and material warranties are advertised; lengths are not published on the website, so ask for the written terms.
    Emergency service
    Available
    Financing
    Available
    Credentials
    BBB accredited, A+ rated
  5. 05

    Best for roof and exterior work handled by one contractor

    All Access Builders LLC

    4.9(142 Google reviews)
    Best forRoof and exterior work handled by one contractor
    In business23 years
    WarrantyManufacturer and workmanship warranties provided in writing on every project, per the company website. Ask for the exact terms and duration.
    EmergencyAvailable

    Why we picked them

    4.9 from 142 Google reviews, a family-owned South Buffalo contractor since 2003 that reviewers say answers its phone.

    What we like

    • Installs GAF, Owens Corning, CertainTeed and IKO shingles
    • Ice and water shield carried well past the interior wall line
    • Open Monday to Saturday per Google, with emergency repair offered

    Things to consider

    • No license number or manufacturer certification tier is published, and it is a general contractor first.

    Services

    • Roof repair
    • Roof replacement
    • Roof inspection
    • Metal roofing
    • Flat roofing
    • Storm damage repair
    Key details
    Best for
    Roof and exterior work handled by one contractor
    Service area
    Buffalo
    Address
    2017 Clinton St
    Years in business
    23 years
    Warranty
    Manufacturer and workmanship warranties provided in writing on every project, per the company website. Ask for the exact terms and duration.
    Emergency service
    Available
    Credentials
    BBB A+ rating, accredited business
  6. 06

    Best for financed full replacements in Black Rock and Riverside

    TurkMasters Roofing Systems

    4.6(74 Google reviews)
    Best forFull roof replacements with financing
    In business22 years
    WarrantyWarranty length is not stated on the company website; ask for written terms.
    EmergencyNot listed

    Why we picked them

    4.6 from 74 Google reviews, with a roofing history back to 2004 and a published 19-page roof replacement guide.

    What we like

    • Hearth financing with 3 to 7 year terms
    • Roof inspections from $125 with a certified letter
    • Reviewers name Moses and JR

    Things to consider

    • Weekday office hours only, and no insurance, warranty length or shingle brand is published.

    Services

    • Roof repair
    • Roof replacement
    • Roof inspection
    Key details
    Best for
    Full roof replacements with financing
    Service area
    Buffalo
    Address
    307 Vulcan St
    Years in business
    22 years
    Warranty
    Warranty length is not stated on the company website; ask for written terms.
    Financing
    Available
  7. 07

    Best for full replacements with long written warranties and financing

    Erie Home Roofing

    4.6(114 Google reviews)
    Best forHomeowners replacing a full roof who want a written long-term warranty and financing
    In business50 years
    WarrantyAsphalt roofs: 30 year limited lifetime warranty (materials and labor for the first 10 years, free materials with homeowner-paid labor for the next 20). Metal roofs: 50 year limited lifetime transferable warranty.
    EmergencyNot listed

    Why we picked them

    4.6 from 113 Google reviews, with a 30 year asphalt warranty and a 50 year transferable metal warranty spelled out.

    What we like

    • Metal and asphalt warranty terms published in full
    • Financing from 12 to 180 months
    • Roofing has its own metal and asphalt pages

    Things to consider

    • Focus is on full replacements, with little on repairs or flat roofs, and the office is in Cheektowaga.

    Services

    • Roof replacement
    • Roof inspection
    • Metal roofing
    Key details
    Best for
    Homeowners replacing a full roof who want a written long-term warranty and financing
    Service area
    Buffalo
    Address
    4950 Genesee St Ste 130, Cheektowaga, NY
    Years in business
    50 years
    Warranty
    Asphalt roofs: 30 year limited lifetime warranty (materials and labor for the first 10 years, free materials with homeowner-paid labor for the next 20). Metal roofs: 50 year limited lifetime transferable warranty.
    Financing
    Available
    Credentials
    Better Business Bureau A+ rating (company-wide, as stated on its site)

Side by Side

Compare the top roofing companies in Buffalo

Ranking position reflects our editorial review, not customer ratings.

Editorial comparison of the 7 ranked companies. Customer ratings, where shown, come from the source named on each company profile.
RankCompanyBest forKey servicesService areaGoogle ratingEmergencyProfile
01Buffalo's Best Roofing Company LLCFast residential re-roofs and storm repairs in Buffalo's eastern suburbsRoof repair, Roof replacement, Roof inspectionBuffalo4.9(773)YesView
02Buffalo RoofingStorm and insurance claim roof replacementsRoof repair, Roof replacement, Roof inspectionBuffalo4.8(397)YesView
03Mann Roofing and RemodelingFull tear-offs and storm repairs on older Buffalo homesRoof repair, Roof replacement, Roof inspectionBuffalo4.7(146)YesView
04Stellar RoofingHomeowners who want a fast full replacement from a large, financed operationRoof repair, Roof replacement, Metal roofingBuffalo4.6(532)YesView
05All Access Builders LLCRoof and exterior work handled by one contractorRoof repair, Roof replacement, Roof inspectionBuffalo4.9(142)YesView
06TurkMasters Roofing SystemsFull roof replacements with financingRoof repair, Roof replacement, Roof inspectionBuffalo4.6(74)Not listedView
07Erie Home RoofingHomeowners replacing a full roof who want a written long-term warranty and financingRoof replacement, Roof inspection, Metal roofingBuffalo4.6(114)Not listedView

Coverage

Roofing companies serving Buffalo and nearby areas

Most companies in this ranking work across New York and the surrounding suburbs. Coverage and travel fees vary, so confirm your address is inside the service area before scheduling.

  • Buffalo

Nearby rankings

Service coverage across Buffalo. Individual company areas are listed on each profile.

Methodology

How we chose the best roofing companies in Buffalo

Companies are listed in the order Google Maps returned them for Buffalo roofing searches on October 22, 2026. Each had at least 4.5 stars, 50 Google reviews, an operating status, a working website, roofing as a core trade and a staffed street address in Buffalo or an adjacent town that names Buffalo as a service area. Firms with mailbox or home addresses, template sites and remodelers with no real roofing pages were left out, so the list has seven entries rather than ten. No company paid for a place.

Read our full ranking methodology
Evaluated7
Ranked7

Hiring

How to choose a roofing company in Buffalo

  1. Verify insurance and credentials

    Ask for a current certificate of insurance and confirm registration or licensing with the authority that issues it, not with the company.

  2. Ask for a written estimate

    Scope, materials, removal, disposal and who pulls the permit should all be named on the page rather than agreed on the doorstep.

  3. Compare multiple quotes

    Two or three bids on the same scope. A number far below the others usually means something has been left out of it.

  4. Understand the warranty

    Separate the manufacturer's warranty on materials from the company's own warranty on the work, and get both in writing.

  5. Ask who performs the work

    Find out whether the crew are employees or subcontractors, and who supervises them on the day.

  6. Check recent local projects

    Ask for addresses or photographs of comparable jobs finished nearby in the last year or two.

  7. Avoid high-pressure sales

    A discount that expires today, or a knock on the door after a storm, is a reason to slow down rather than sign.

  8. Get everything in writing

    Change orders, timeline and payment schedule included, before the first payment changes hands.

Questions to ask before hiring

0 of 10 asked

Red flags

  • No verifiable local business address or registration
  • Pressure to sign on the first visit
  • A demand for full payment up front
  • An offer to cover or waive your insurance deductible
  • Refusal to put warranty terms in writing
  • A quote that will not itemize scope

Keep Going

Related home services in Buffalo

Roofing guides for Buffalo homeowners

FAQ

Roofing companies in Buffalo FAQs

Do roofers need a licence in Buffalo, NY?

New York State does not license roofers, but Erie County requires a home improvement license, so check the contractor on the Erie County Department of Consumer Protection lookup. Also ask for a workers' compensation certificate, a liability insurance certificate and the permit for your address, and get the warranty in writing.

How much does a new roof cost in Buffalo?

None of these companies publishes a fixed price, because cost depends on roof size, pitch, the number of old layers and the material. Asphalt shingles cost far less than stone-coated steel or standing seam metal, and extra layers of old shingles add tear-off labor. Get at least two written, itemized quotes and compare the warranty terms.

How do I prevent ice dams on a Buffalo roof?

Ice dams form when heat escaping from the attic melts snow that then refreezes at the eaves. The fix is usually better attic insulation and ventilation, plus ice and water shield membrane along the eaves during a reroof. Ask any roofer how far the membrane will extend past the interior wall line and what they do about ventilation.

Editorial Record

About this ranking

Originally published
October 2026
Last reviewed
October 2026
Reviewed by
Marcus Reed, Expert reviewer, exteriors and structure
Companies evaluated
7

Need a roofing company in Buffalo?

Or compare the Buffalo roofing companies again