Researched rankings in 38 cities across the United States and Canada, each with a last-reviewed date.

TenBestFindThe best, verified
Add Your Business

Islanders' Choice Painting Co

Painting Company in Victoria, British Columbia.

Islanders' Choice Painting Co is a painting company based in Victoria, BC. Its listed services include interior painting, exterior painting and cabinet refinishing. Its Licensed and insured (stated, no number published) is reported by the company and not yet verified, so check it with Stated by company before work starts.

4.9on Google · 247 reviews7 years in business
  • TenBestFind Reviewed
  • Top 10 Winner
  • iWhat do these badges mean?
    TenBestFind Reviewed
    Our editorial team has researched and reviewed this business.
    Verified Business
    Key business information or ownership has been verified against a primary source.
    Top 10 Winner
    The company currently appears in at least one active TenBestFind Top 10 ranking.
    Featured Partner
    A paid commercial relationship with TenBestFind. It never earns or influences a ranking position. This company holds no such relationship.

    Advertising & Sponsorship Disclosure

Quick Overview

iHow this is made

This summary is generated from the verified data on this profile: services, service area, credentials, warranty terms and the company's Google review record. It is reviewed by an editor before publishing and refreshed whenever the underlying data changes. Nothing here is asserted that is not stated elsewhere on this page.

Editorial Standards

Islanders' Choice Painting Co has served Greater Victoria since 2019 from a shop on Fifth Street, founded by Evan and Dave, who split the work between customer systems and field production. The website claims a team of more than 30 painters, over 2,000 completed projects and Sherwin-Williams products, backed by a three year workmanship warranty. Services cover interior and exterior house painting, cabinet painting, deck and fence painting, epoxy floors and kitchen makeovers, plus commercial and strata work. Islanders' Choice holds 4.9 stars from 247 Google reviews, read November 3, 2026, the second largest review base in this list. It suits homeowners with big jobs who want project managers and a large crew. A small one room touch up may feel oversized for a company this size.

  • Best for larger interior and exterior jobs needing project management
  • Founded in 2019 by Evan and Dave, who share management and field roles
  • A 30 plus painter company works through managers, so the owners are less likely to be on site.

Company Facts

Islanders' Choice Painting Co at a Glance

By the numbers

Google rating
4.9out of 5
Customer reviews
247on Google
In business
7years

Rating and review count pulled from Google on November 3, 2026. Years counted from 2019.

The work

Best for
Larger interior and exterior jobs needing project management
Primary service
Painting

Where

Headquarters
Victoria, BC
Service area
Victoria
Emergency service
Not advertised

Money and guarantees

Free estimates
Yes
Financing
Not advertised
Workmanship warranty
Three year workmanship warranty, as stated on the company website.

Credentials

Licensed and insured (stated, no number published)
Licensed and insured (stated, no number published) (reported by the company, not verified)

Editorial Review

Our Take on Islanders' Choice Painting Co

One of the larger painting operations in Greater Victoria, with named founders, a stated 30 plus painters and 247 Google reviews at 4.9. Strong on process and warranty, less personal than a small owner crew.

Best forLarger interior and exterior jobs needing project management

What We Like

  • Founded in 2019 by Evan and Dave, who share management and field roles
  • Team of more than 30 painters stated, with project managers on jobs
  • Three year workmanship warranty stated on the website
  • Sherwin-Williams products stated, with cabinets, decks and epoxy floors offered
  • 4.9 stars from 247 Google reviews, read November 3, 2026

Things to Consider

  • A 30 plus painter company works through managers, so the owners are less likely to be on site.
  • The site advertises a limited time discount, so confirm it does not change paint grade or scope.
  • The phone number on the website differs from the one on Google, which is listed here, and no licence number or insurance amount is published.

Customer Ratings

Google Reviews for Islanders' Choice Painting Co

Customer ratings shown here come from Google. They are separate from our editorial review above.

Google rating

4.9

Based on 247 Google reviews

Review data updated November 3, 2026

View on Google Maps

Rating Distribution

  • 5 stars97%
  • 4 stars1%
  • 3 stars1%
  • 1 star2%
iAbout this distribution

The distribution reflects the 247 Google reviews available when this profile's review data was last refreshed on November 3, 2026. Ratings and counts change continuously on Google, so figures here may lag the live profile slightly. We publish only the values returned by the source, never estimates for missing bands.

Editorial Standards

Recent Google Reviews

  • Irene Stevens5.0

    We are extremely happy with the work done by Islanders' Choice Painting. Keenan came to our home to discuss our requirements and prepared a quote for us. We needed work done in a number of areas in the house. Reece was the project lead and did a great job of monitoring the work and doing a final walk through. JJ and his team of painters were friendly, on time and did a wonderful job. All members of Islanders' Choice Painting were professional and we would highly recommend them.

    October 2026Google
  • Nina Hirlaender (Dancing Spirit Tours)5.0

    Islanders Choice Painting was a pleasure to work with from start to finish. From the very first visit, Keenan (sales representative) was attentive to the unique features of my heritage house and coach house. The project involved six different colours, and the team brought care and attention to the work. Whenever I had a special request, they went above and beyond to accommodate it.<br><br>Evan and Vanessa (accounting) were communicative and efficient, making the administrative side easy. Julian and Reece (project leads) were excellent communicators who really took the time to listen and execute the project with care. They followed through on repairs and finishing touches, even after the project was finished, to make sure every detail was handled professionally.<br><br>I really appreciated the whole team’s responsiveness and commitment to getting things right. Highly recommend! ✅

    October 2026Google
  • Joy E1.0

    Disrespectful front desk.<br><br>Oh the owner requires a written review. I don’t have to hire you to give you a review. Your front desk needs to be respectful first. That is all I will say. Send all you want to google. I can give a review if I interacted with your company. Rather than trying to resolve the problem by asking what has gone wrong you are trying to delete my review. I understand how you have only 5 stars.<br><br>Oh by the way I will also send a message to Google and say that you are trying to delete a review you didn’t like without even trying to contact me. If my review deleted from here I will make sure give you another review until it permanently stays here. You need to be able to receive negative review.

    October 2026Google
  • Adam Davidson1.0

    After contacting this business only once, they kept sending emails and text messages even I told them not to text me after so many. They said they will stop but after this last message. It blew my mind. I said whatever and a few days later they texted again! Very pushy system. It is weird that you send a message to Google sir. You can’t take a negative review?

    October 2026Google
  • Kelly Y1.0

    The secretary absolutely have no respect, no matter have many times I said I do not want to receive any texts they kept texting and emailing me! Ended up blocking but I make sure to add this as a comment so someone fix the issue.

    October 2026Google
  • louise england5.0

    Excellent large organization with owner project manager and painter all super professional and catered to my rush schedule with back up painters had that been needed<br>Price came down to compeditive after I did all the prep

    September 2026Google

View more Google reviews

Ranked#3of 10 painting companies in Victoria, BCre-checked November 2026

Editorial Ranking

Why Islanders' Choice Painting Co Made Our Top 10

It holds position 3 in 10 Best Painting Companies in Victoria, BC (2026).

See the Full Victoria RankingPositions cannot be bought

Areas Served

Based in Victoria, BC.

iAbout service coverage

Coverage is as the business describes it, cross-checked against where its recent documented work is. A company will often travel beyond the areas listed here for a large job and decline a small one at the same distance, so confirm your address before scheduling.

Editorial Standards

Company Background

About Islanders' Choice Painting Co

Islanders' Choice Painting Co was founded in 2019 by Evan and Dave, who say they started it to become the most trusted painter in Victoria rather than the biggest. According to the company, Evan focused on systems, communication and the customer experience, while Dave took production and quality control in the field. The shop and office are at 2938 Fifth Street, with a posted schedule of 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. every day.

The website lists a team of more than 30 painters, over 2,000 completed projects and zero BBB complaints. Work covers residential interior and exterior painting, cabinet painting, deck and fence painting, epoxy floors and countertops, and kitchen makeovers, along with commercial, strata and commercial epoxy floor work. The company states it uses Sherwin-Williams products, is locally owned, licensed and insured, and gives a three year workmanship warranty.

The service area named on the site is Victoria, Oak Bay, Langford, Saanich and Sidney, with Sooke also mentioned. A project manager is assigned to each job, which helps on whole house repaints where trades overlap, but it also means a larger operation than a single owner crew.

Islanders' Choice Painting Co holds 4.9 stars from 247 Google reviews, read November 3, 2026, and sits third in the Google Maps order used for this list.

It suits owners of larger homes, strata buildings and anyone who wants a structured process with a named project manager. It suits less well a homeowner who wants the owner on the tools every day, since a 30 plus painter company works through managers. The website also advertises a limited time discount, so ask whether any offer changes the scope or the paint grade. Before booking, ask for the quote in writing with brand and coats listed, ask for the warranty in writing, and ask for the current WorkSafeBC clearance letter. British Columbia has no provincial painter licence, so confirm a municipal business licence too.

iWhere this information comes from

Company history, ownership and capability details on this page are provided by the business and reviewed by our editors for plausibility and consistency. They are not the same as the credentials block, where each item carries its own verification status and source.

Editorial Standards

Credentials

  • Licensed and insured (stated, no number published)Stated by companyReported
iWhat verified means here

Verified means we checked the credential against the authority that issues it and recorded the date. Reported means the business told us and we could not independently confirm it. We publish both, labelled, rather than dropping what we could not check.

Editorial Standards

Other Sources

Reputation by Source

We show each source separately rather than blending them into a single score, because they measure different things.

  • Google

    4.9/ 5

    247 customer reviews

  • TenBestFind

    Editorially reviewed

    Ranked #3 in Victoria painting, November 2026

Pricing

Company Pricing & Estimates

What this company publishes about its own pricing.

Free estimates
Yes
Workmanship warranty
Three year workmanship warranty, as stated on the company website.

Gallery

Project Photos

Business-submitted, reviewed by our editors

  • Islanders' Choice Painting CoIslanders' Choice Painting Co
  • Islanders' Choice Painting CoIslanders' Choice Painting Co
  • Islanders' Choice Painting CoIslanders' Choice Painting Co
  • Islanders' Choice Painting CoIslanders' Choice Painting Co

Compare

Similar Painting companies in Victoria

Islanders' Choice Painting Co FAQs

  • What are Islanders' Choice Painting's hours?

    Google and the website both list 8 a.m. to 5 p.m., seven days a week, at 2938 Fifth Street. It is a scheduled painting company rather than an emergency service, so book an estimate by calling 778-902-4589 on Google or the number printed on the website.

  • What warranty and service area does Islanders' Choice Painting offer?

    The company states a three year workmanship warranty. Its service area includes Victoria, Oak Bay, Langford, Saanich and Sidney. Ask for the warranty wording and for the quote to list the paint brand and number of coats, since the website names Sherwin-Williams as its supplier.

  • Is Islanders' Choice Painting Co licensed and insured?

    We checked 0 of 1 credentials against the issuing authority. Verified items carry the date we checked; reported items are what the business told us and we could not independently confirm.

  • What areas does Islanders' Choice Painting Co serve?

    Victoria. Coverage is as the business describes it, cross-checked against where its recent documented work is. Confirm your address before scheduling, particularly at the edge of a service area.

  • Does Islanders' Choice Painting Co offer emergency service?

    Emergency availability is not listed for this company. If you need an urgent call-out, check the ranking for companies that do list it.

  • What warranty do they offer?

    Three year workmanship warranty, as stated on the company website.. There are usually two warranties on a job: the manufacturer covers materials, the contractor covers workmanship. Get both in writing and check whether the workmanship coverage transfers if you sell.

  • How was this profile built?

    Credentials come from issuing authorities, ratings from the company's Google Business Profile with the date we read them, and the editorial take from our own review of estimates, warranty documents and public feedback. Anything the business told us is labelled as reported.

  • Can a business pay to improve its profile?

    A business can subscribe to manage its own listing details, and it can buy a labelled sponsored placement. Neither changes a ranking position or the editorial assessment on this page.

Is Something Incorrect?

Business information changes. Tell us about an address, phone, website, service area, credential or ownership change, or let us know if this company has closed.

Suggest an Update

Own Islanders' Choice Painting Co?

Claim your profile to verify and maintain your business information, services and service area.

Claim This Business
iWhat claiming does

Claiming lets you correct and maintain the factual information on this profile. Claiming or upgrading a profile does not guarantee inclusion in a TenBestFind ranking and never affects ranking position, which is decided editorially.

How We Rank

About This Business Profile

Last reviewed
November 2026
Profile last updated
November 11, 2026
Google review data updated
November 3, 2026
Sources checked
Issuing authorities, Google Business Profile, Company website
Could not verify
Licensed and insured (stated, no number published) (reported only)
Sponsorship status
No commercial relationship
Islanders' Choice Painting Co4.9 on Google · Victoria, BCVisit Website