Researched rankings in 38 cities across the United States and Canada, each with a last-reviewed date.

TenBestFindThe best, verified
Add Your Business

Nicholson Builders

Remodeling Company in Columbus, Ohio.

Nicholson Builders is a remodeling contractor based in Columbus, OH. Its listed services include kitchen remodeling, bathroom remodeling, basement remodeling and home additions. It has not published a license number, so ask for one and check it before any work starts.

4.8on Google · 75 reviews23 years in business
  • TenBestFind Reviewed
  • Top 10 Winner
  • iWhat do these badges mean?
    TenBestFind Reviewed
    Our editorial team has researched and reviewed this business.
    Verified Business
    Key business information or ownership has been verified against a primary source.
    Top 10 Winner
    The company currently appears in at least one active TenBestFind Top 10 ranking.
    Featured Partner
    A paid commercial relationship with TenBestFind. It never earns or influences a ranking position. This company holds no such relationship.

    Advertising & Sponsorship Disclosure

Quick Overview

iHow this is made

This summary is generated from the verified data on this profile: services, service area, credentials, warranty terms and the company's Google review record. It is reviewed by an editor before publishing and refreshed whenever the underlying data changes. Nothing here is asserted that is not stated elsewhere on this page.

Editorial Standards

Nicholson Builders is a design-build remodeler founded in 2003 by Bill Nicholson and Mike Fought, working from 6525 Busch Boulevard in Columbus. Its team includes a registered architect, certified kitchen and bath designers and project managers, and it also runs a small-projects crew. Homeowners rate it 4.8 from 75 Google reviews, read October 31, 2026. The office is by appointment only and keeps Monday to Friday hours, 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. The website lists no licence number or warranty terms, so ask for both in writing before signing.

  • Best for luxury kitchens, additions and whole-home design-build
  • Founded in 2003 by Bill Nicholson and Mike Fought
  • The office is by appointment only and closed to walk-in visitors

Company Facts

Nicholson Builders at a Glance

By the numbers

Google rating
4.8out of 5
Customer reviews
75on Google
In business
23years

Rating and review count pulled from Google on October 31, 2026. Years counted from 2003.

The work

Best for
Luxury kitchens, additions and whole-home design-build
Primary service
Remodeling

Where

Headquarters
Columbus, OH
Service area
Columbus
Emergency service
Not advertised

Money and guarantees

Free estimates
Not advertised
Financing
Not advertised

Credentials

License number
Not published

Editorial Review

Our Take on Nicholson Builders

A large design team with a registered architect and certified kitchen designers, aimed at bigger jobs. Verify licensing and warranty terms because the site does not publish them.

Best forLuxury kitchens, additions and whole-home design-build

What We Like

  • Founded in 2003 by Bill Nicholson and Mike Fought
  • Team includes registered architect John Nicholson and CKBD-credentialed designers
  • Handles kitchens, bathrooms, additions, basements and small projects
  • Reviews describe multi-month first-floor renovations and repeat projects
  • Publishes a cost and investment page and a detailed team page

Things to Consider

  • The office is by appointment only and closed to walk-in visitors
  • No licence number, insurance details or warranty terms on the website
  • A large design-led process suits bigger jobs more than quick single repairs

Customer Ratings

Google Reviews for Nicholson Builders

Customer ratings shown here come from Google. They are separate from our editorial review above.

Google rating

4.8

Based on 75 Google reviews

Review data updated October 31, 2026

View on Google Maps

Rating Distribution

  • 5 stars95%
  • 3 stars1%
  • 2 stars1%
  • 1 star3%
iAbout this distribution

The distribution reflects the 75 Google reviews available when this profile's review data was last refreshed on October 31, 2026. Ratings and counts change continuously on Google, so figures here may lag the live profile slightly. We publish only the values returned by the source, never estimates for missing bands.

Editorial Standards

Recent Google Reviews

  • Hilda Meson5.0

    Can't get enough of your designs! The unique aesthetic and flawless execution are simply breathtaking. Count me as your biggest fan from MesonArt!

    November 2025Google
  • Lori Murray5.0

    We could not be more pleased with the work that Nicholson Builders did in our home. Not only was the work professionally done, but the workers were a pleasure as well. During the many weeks they were here, they arrived on time, cleaned up when they were done, and knew how to handle every situation that came up. It's nice to finally find a trustworthy company that does exceptional work!

    June 2025Google
  • Marc Solomon5.0

    We bought our house in 2023 knowing it needed a lot of work. One of the biggest issues was an awkward floorplan and small kitchen on the 1st floor that wasn't working for our growing family.<br><br>We partnered with Nicholson Builders on a major renovation project that ran from May to September 2024. The results were transformational and we couldn't be happier with the end result! The new space is modern, functional, and beautiful.<br><br>Everyone we interacted with including the design consultants, architect, and project manager demonstrated attention to detail, professionalism, and excellence in customer service.<br><br>When problems came up, mostly because of mistakes made by subcontractors, the Nicholson team jumped in and solved them quickly. You can really tell that they stand behind their work and have a company culture that values customer satisfaction.<br><br>I highly recommend Nicholas Builders if you can afford their high quality services.

    March 2025Google
  • David5.0

    I can't speak highly enough about the experience we had with Nicholson Builders. We had there small projects team come out and do the flooring for the upstairs portion of the house. They were so great about keeping lines of communication open, keeping us updated and getting things done as efficiently as possible.<br>We live in German Village and therefore have an old home. The upstairs flooring was bouncy and squeaky and those were the main reasons for the flooring update. I cant believe that they were able to get rid of every sinlge noise and every single uneven portion of flooring. They said they could snd they delivered in that. It has truly transformed the whole space.<br>I also want to give a huge shout out to the team that came out and did the actual work. It's super important to feel comfortable with people who are coming into your home and these gentlemen were extremely nice, very professional and super tidy. The way they took care of every single detail and left the space looking not the same but BETTER than the way they found it was outstanding. You might pay a little more for the work that Nicholson Builders do, but you are definitely going to get the best results. We absolutely will be using them for our next project.

    March 2025Google
  • Andy Vasani5.0

    Promises made ..promises kept....quality people quality work !<br>Honoring workmanship warranty honored after 10 years....(not a written warranty) which included material and labor (most warranties, if they are even honored will not cover both)

    February 2025Google
  • Charles Caldwell5.0

    Recently, we had maintenance work done on our home by Nicholson Builder’s Small Projects Department. It was great to find someone to do minor to moderate repairs that are beyond the time and/or capacity of typical homeowners. We scheduled and worked out the details with Dan McCallister, Paul Batchelder, Bryan Copley and Madison Wichael who were all very knowledgeable, prompt and fair. James Yoder performed the work, and he was detailed and did an excellent job. Overall, we were very satisfied with the whole experience and will keep Nicholson Builder’s on speed dial.

    December 2024Google

View more Google reviews

Ranked#2of 5 general contractors in Columbus, OHre-checked October 2026

Editorial Ranking

Why Nicholson Builders Made Our Top 5

It holds position 2 in 5 Best General Contractors in Columbus, OH (2026).

See the Full Columbus RankingResearched by Priya Nathan · positions cannot be bought

Areas Served

Based in Columbus, OH.

iAbout service coverage

Coverage is as the business describes it, cross-checked against where its recent documented work is. A company will often travel beyond the areas listed here for a large job and decline a small one at the same distance, so confirm your address before scheduling.

Editorial Standards

Company Background

About Nicholson Builders

Nicholson Builders was founded in 2003 when Bill Nicholson and Mike Fought started the firm after years with other Columbus remodelers. It works from 6525 Busch Boulevard in north Columbus, though the office is by appointment only and closed to walk-in visitors. The company describes its services as design-build remodeling, small projects and decorating, and its portfolio covers kitchens, bathrooms, additions and exteriors, and living spaces such as basements, offices and mudrooms.

The Google rating is 4.8 from 75 reviews, read October 31, 2026. Reviewers describe a full rebuild of a brick front porch, a foyer ceiling and a shower remodel done over several projects, a major first-floor renovation that ran from May to September 2024 to fix an awkward floor plan and small kitchen, and a kitchen and sunroom planned from scratch. One owner praises the range of skills offered, from design consulting to the carpentry itself. A restaurant owner had window frames built to fit and says the company coordinated with the glass supplier.

The team page is unusually detailed. It lists registered architect John Nicholson, design leader Erik Maxwell, sales leader Jeremy Little, who is an architect and designer, and designers Amy Statler and Doug Lugar, who both hold the CKBD kitchen and bath credential from NKBA. The firm also names project managers and carpenters.

There are gaps. The website does not publish a licence number, insurance details, warranty terms or prices beyond a cost-and-investment page, and it says only that it stands behind its work. With a large design staff, expect a structured process that suits bigger jobs.

Nicholson suits owners planning an addition, a kitchen with layout changes or a whole-first-floor renovation who want architects and designers under one roof. It suits less well anyone who wants a quick quote on a single repair, although the small-projects crew exists. Before booking, ask for the written scope, the design fee structure, the warranty terms and the contractor registration number. Ohio has no state licence for residential remodeling, so check City of Columbus building and zoning services and the Ohio Construction Industry Licensing Board.

iWhere this information comes from

Company history, ownership and capability details on this page are provided by the business and reviewed by our editors for plausibility and consistency. They are not the same as the credentials block, where each item carries its own verification status and source.

Editorial Standards

Other Sources

Reputation by Source

We show each source separately rather than blending them into a single score, because they measure different things.

  • Google

    4.8/ 5

    75 customer reviews

  • TenBestFind

    Editorially reviewed

    Ranked #2 in Columbus general contractors, October 2026

Gallery

Project Photos

Business-submitted, reviewed by our editors

  • Nicholson BuildersNicholson Builders
  • Nicholson BuildersNicholson Builders
  • Nicholson BuildersNicholson Builders
  • Nicholson BuildersNicholson Builders

Compare

Similar Home Remodeling in Columbus

Nicholson Builders FAQs

  • Is Nicholson Builders licensed in Columbus?

    The Nicholson Builders website does not list a licence number, so ask for one in writing. Ohio has no state general contractor licence for residential remodeling. Check the company with City of Columbus building and zoning services, and confirm any plumbing, electrical or HVAC trade licences with the Ohio Construction Industry Licensing Board. The team page does list a registered architect, John Nicholson.

  • Can I visit the Nicholson Builders office?

    By appointment only. The office at 6525 Busch Boulevard is closed to the public, and the company keeps Monday to Friday hours from 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Call (614) 846-7388 or email info@nicholsonbuilders.com to set a meeting.

  • What does Nicholson Builders say about its warranty and costs?

    The company says it stands behind its work but does not publish warranty terms, so ask for them in writing. Its website has a cost and investment page that explains what thoughtful remodeling typically costs. Services are design-build remodeling, small projects and decorating across Columbus and Central Ohio.

  • Is Nicholson Builders licensed and insured?

    We have no credential records on file for this company yet. Ask for the certificate directly from the insurer before booking work.

  • What areas does Nicholson Builders serve?

    Columbus. Coverage is as the business describes it, cross-checked against where its recent documented work is. Confirm your address before scheduling, particularly at the edge of a service area.

  • Does Nicholson Builders offer emergency service?

    Emergency availability is not listed for this company. If you need an urgent call-out, check the ranking for companies that do list it.

  • What warranty do they offer?

    Warranty terms are not on file. Ask for them in writing before work starts.

  • How was this profile built?

    Credentials come from issuing authorities, ratings from the company's Google Business Profile with the date we read them, and the editorial take from our own review of estimates, warranty documents and public feedback. Anything the business told us is labelled as reported.

  • Can a business pay to improve its profile?

    A business can subscribe to manage its own listing details, and it can buy a labelled sponsored placement. Neither changes a ranking position or the editorial assessment on this page.

Is Something Incorrect?

Business information changes. Tell us about an address, phone, website, service area, credential or ownership change, or let us know if this company has closed.

Suggest an Update

Own Nicholson Builders?

Claim your profile to verify and maintain your business information, services and service area.

Claim This Business
iWhat claiming does

Claiming lets you correct and maintain the factual information on this profile. Claiming or upgrading a profile does not guarantee inclusion in a TenBestFind ranking and never affects ranking position, which is decided editorially.

How We Rank

About This Business Profile

Last reviewed
October 2026
Profile last updated
November 11, 2026
Google review data updated
October 31, 2026
Reviewed by
Priya Nathan, Staff writer, remodeling and moving
Sources checked
Google Business Profile, Company website
Could not verify
License (none published), insurance
Sponsorship status
No commercial relationship

Priya writes the remodeling, moving and cost guides. She spends most of her time reading contracts and estimates, which is where the differences between two apparently identical quotes usually turn up.

Nicholson Builders4.8 on Google · Columbus, OHVisit Website